Community
Participate
Working Groups
I set up a simple query the other night to calculate the number of committers per project / topproject (using the `SELECT DISTINCT TOPPROJECT, PROJECT from commits`): [1]http://dash.eclipse.org/dash/commits/web-api/commit-committers-by-project.php?debug [2]http://dash.eclipse.org/dash/commits/web-api/commit-committers-by-project.php Unfortunately, it appears to be missing data, as this query returns only one committer: # SELECT DISTINCT LOGIN FROM commits_index WHERE PROJECT='stp' ohurley Looking at the filesystem on dev.eclipse for ~/downloads/stp, I see six file owners: ndai, askehill, catrielo, ohurley, jma, sdrapeau Checking their groups: $ groups ndai askehill catrielo ohurley jma sdrapeau ndai : common webtools webtools-home stp-dev stpadmin webtoolsadmin webtools.incubator-dev webtools.incubator-home webtools.incubatoradmin stp-svn webtools.all webtools.common-dev webtools.ejbtools-dev webtools.jeetools-dev webtools.releng-dev webtools.servertools-dev webtools.sourceediting-dev webtools.webservices-dev askehill : common signers stp-dev stpadmin stp-home stp-svn catrielo : common stp-main stp-dev stpadmin stp-home stp-svn ohurley : common stp-dev stpadmin stp-home callisto-dev stp-svn jma : common stp-dev stpadmin stp-home stp-svn sdrapeau : common stp-dev stp-home stp-svn stp.sca-download Checking the subversion repo, I see files owned by: azoppello, dbosschae, amarkevic, amos, atoulme, sdrapeau, amiguel, nbagnard, gpreissle, achen, ashakirin, qhuang, jma, dxu, askehill, ejuliot, hmalphett, ohurley Checking their groups: $ groups azoppello dbosschae amarkevic amos atoulme sdrapeau amiguel nbagnard gpreissle achen ashakirin qhuang jma dxu askehill ejuliot hmalphett ohhurley azoppello : common stp-home stp-svn dbosschae : common stp-dev stp-home stp-svn amarkevic : common stp-home stp-svn amos : common stp-home stp-svn stp.model-download atoulme : common stp-dev stp-home emft-compare emft-compare-releng stp-svn sdrapeau : common stp-dev stp-home stp-svn stp.sca-download id: cannot find name for group ID 8144 nbagnard : common stp-home stp-svn stp.eid-download gpreissle : common stp-home technology-svn swordfish-dev stp-svn stp.policy-download achen : common stp-dev stp-svn ashakirin : common stp-home stp-svn qhuang : common stp-dev stp-home stp-svn jma : common stp-dev stpadmin stp-home stp-svn dxu : common stp-dev stp-home stp-svn askehill : common signers stp-dev stpadmin stp-home stp-svn ejuliot : common stp-dev stp-home stp-svn hmalphett : common stp-dev stp-home stp-svn ohurley : common stp-dev stpadmin stp-home callisto-dev stp-svn Overall, that's 20 committers (assuming amiguel is valid, despite the group lookup error). --- It would seem this is not strictly an SVN issue. Overall, the above URL [2] returns 64 committers for Modeling, including two I've never heard of, Brahim Khalil Loukil (modeling.gmt, bloukil) & Daniel Varro (modeling.gmt, dvarro). These two are NOT in my photo database [3], suggesting that either I have people listed who aren't committers or some folks are missing from Dash. [3]http://www.eclipse.org/modeling/team/ I suspect it's missing data, given the commit activity this month for bloukil in: /cvsroot/technology/org.eclipse.gmt/AM3/plugins/org.eclipse.gmt.am3.platform.core/src/org/eclipse/gmt/am3/platform/core/
amiguel is valid - and he has been on to me to tell me that he can't currently make commits to his component (which is org.eclipse.stp.b2j). All those 20 committers you have listed are correct. I'll get the committer spreadsheet up to date and send it on to EMO.
Something completely blew up over the weekend. Dash failed to communicate to dev.eclipse.org and thus nothing is working properly. I will have to re-run the batch job before I can look into data issues.
Closing as resolved.
The data is back but it's still incorrect. Please re-read comment 0 and comment 1. The STP data still shows it's all Oisin, all the time. :) He may be prolific, but he's not the *only* team member. Oisin: Are you the only *active* committer? http://www.eclipse.org/projects/project_summary.php?projectid=stp
Maybe the problem is that there are a number of missing subprojects? For example, I see a number of subprojects listed on this page [1]: [1]http://www.eclipse.org/projects/project_summary.php?projectid=stp but when I click on a link to that project's summary [2], I see no active committers, and the commits_index table apparently does not contain these records either. [2] http://www.eclipse.org/projects/project_summary.php?projectid=stp.sca
One problem is that we're in between standardized groups and not... and the projects page terminology has been re-done for the new setup, where these are called "sub-projects" but in reality they are "components" in this case. I am going to revisit how we label that. The "bug" here, however is that STP does not have correct repository information in the meta-data. All of the CVS repositories are not listed, for example. Transferring to STP.
> The "bug" here, however is that STP does not have correct repository > information in the meta-data. All of the CVS repositories are not listed, for > example. Transferring to STP. I'll go check the metadata - from the dash page the repo addresses are incorrect.
Created attachment 95126 [details] Portal screenshot
My portal looks well sick - check the screenshot attached. Where is all the other good stuff gone - the committer nominations, the project data editing capabilities etc? What am I missing?
Now (a few months later) I'm seeing lots of commits in the commits explorer for STP. I consider this bug fixed.
