Bugzilla – Full Text Bug Listing
| Summary: | Migrate EMO content to Gerrit | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Product: | Community | Reporter: | Christopher Guindon <chris.guindon> |
| Component: | Website | Assignee: | phoenix.ui <phoenix.ui-inbox> |
| Status: | RESOLVED FIXED | QA Contact: | |
| Severity: | normal | ||
| Priority: | P3 | CC: | anne.jacko, denis.roy, edouard, ian.skerrett, mike.milinkovich, sharon.corbett, thanh.ha |
| Version: | unspecified | ||
| Target Milestone: | --- | ||
| Hardware: | PC | ||
| OS: | Mac OS X | ||
| Whiteboard: | |||
|
Description
Christopher Guindon
This is fixed for these projects, all I had to do was set the permissions parent to the permissions/www-auth project (inherited). - downloads - eclipse.org-common - home - ide - membership - projects The remaining ones I can't do because they are not Gerrit projects. Who do I need to get a +1 from to migrate all of these repos to Gerrit? List: - articles - artwork - committers - community - corporate_sponsors - donate - eclipse4 - friends - org - resources - users
>
> The remaining ones I can't do because they are not Gerrit projects. Who do I
> need to get a +1 from to migrate all of these repos to Gerrit?
>
> List:
>
> - articles
> - artwork
> - committers
> - community
> - corporate_sponsors
> - donate
> - eclipse4
> - friends
> - org
> - resources
> - users
+1 from me but I think we need a +1 from Denis before moving forward with this.
+1 I migrated the listed websites and assigned the www-auth permissions. (In reply to Christopher Guindon from comment #2) > > - articles > > - artwork > > - committers > > - community > > - corporate_sponsors > > - donate > > - eclipse4 > > - friends > > - org > > - resources > > - users Let's map out the other repos that are maintained by Foundation staff, either migrate them to Gerrit and provide some training, or revert them to plain Git. I edit my web pages (primarily legal and org) via an Orion instance running on localhost. Can someone help me understand what my workflow will become? Does this mean that after I commit the code from Orion that I will need to also interact with Gerrit? (In reply to Denis Roy from comment #5) > (In reply to Christopher Guindon from comment #2) > > > - articles > > > - artwork > > > - committers > > > - community > > > - corporate_sponsors > > > - donate > > > - eclipse4 > > > - friends > > > - org > > > - resources > > > - users > > Let's map out the other repos that are maintained by Foundation staff, > either migrate them to Gerrit and provide some training, or revert them to > plain Git. According to https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AsQLOtRdqwM9dHBEcGdUYVU3WmFTQXpySGNUNG9xX3c&usp=drive_web#gid=0 10years arch articles artwork callisto committers community contribute corporate_sponsors documentation donate downloads eclipse.org-common eclipse4 errors europa galileo ganymede go home images indigo juno kepler legal licenses luna mail membership mobile mpc newsgroups org phoenix-test projects resources screenshots users (In reply to Mike Milinkovich from comment #6) > I edit my web pages (primarily legal and org) via an Orion instance running > on localhost. > > Can someone help me understand what my workflow will become? Does this mean > that after I commit the code from Orion that I will need to also interact > with Gerrit? If you want simply change the git URL to the gerrit one, you don't need to do anything differently (gerrit won't force you to use it's review system - it'll just push things right through to the git repo). If you want to use the review system you just have to push to the /refs/for/branch_name branch instead of the typical branch_name. I don't use Orion, but in command line it would look something like this: # Switch from Git to Gerrit remote origin git remote rm origin git remote add origin ssh://gerrit url here # Push directly to master branch on git repo: git push origin master # The usual # Push to gerrit in order to review a push to master: git push origin HEAD:/refs/for/master # Once it's reviewed and pushed in the Gerrit UI, it'll appear in the git repo in the master branch. Hope that helps. (In reply to Mike Milinkovich from comment #6) > I edit my web pages (primarily legal and org) via an Orion instance running > on localhost. > > Can someone help me understand what my workflow will become? Does this mean > that after I commit the code from Orion that I will need to also interact > with Gerrit? +1 is there documentation on how to use Gerrit that someone can point to? (In reply to Ian Skerrett from comment #9) > (In reply to Mike Milinkovich from comment #6) > > I edit my web pages (primarily legal and org) via an Orion instance running > > on localhost. > > > > Can someone help me understand what my workflow will become? Does this mean > > that after I commit the code from Orion that I will need to also interact > > with Gerrit? > > +1 is there documentation on how to use Gerrit that someone can point to? Denis wrote a good blog post about Gerrit: http://eclipsewebmaster.blogspot.ca/2013/11/using-gerrit-code-review-without-code.html There also the Eclipse wiki page for Gerrit that you could take a look at: https://wiki.eclipse.org/Gerrit Guys, I do appreciate all the pointers. But I simply do not have time to go read stuff and figure it out. Please pretend I am an utter moron (that won't be hard) and spoon feed me _exactly_ what I need to do. (In reply to Mike Milinkovich from comment #11) > Guys, > > I do appreciate all the pointers. But I simply do not have time to go read > stuff and figure it out. Please pretend I am an utter moron (that won't be > hard) and spoon feed me _exactly_ what I need to do. First, you need to link your public ssh key with Gerrit and update your remote url. After this initial setup, you should be able to push to git/gerrit the same way you where doing it before. 1. Sign in to Gerrit: https://git.eclipse.org/r/login/q/status:open,n,z 2. Copy your public SSH key: https://git.eclipse.org/r/#/settings/ssh-keys 3. Update remote URLS: You need to find the project on Gerrit web ui https://git.eclipse.org/r/ If the project is missing, it's because it's not setup to use Gerrit. You will need to use the urls from cgit https://git.eclipse.org/c/ 3.1 Search for the project. (This page is also available from the Projects link in the main menu of Gerrit web ui): https://git.eclipse.org/r/#/admin/projects/ To filter out non www.eclipse.org repo, start with typing www.eclipse.org in the filter box. 3.2 Click on www.eclipse.org/org 3.3 Click on SSH for the Gerrit remote URL. If you need to update an existing repo, please ignore "git clone" and only copy ssh://... 4. Update remote url: You can do this with the command line. git remote set-url origin ssh://git.eclipse.org:29418/www.eclipse.org/org You can also update the remote url with eclipse git perspective. Mike, I can definitely help you with this today if you have a few minutes for me. Denis, is it possible for us to automatically create a redirect for old git urls to the new Gerrit urls when we migrate a repo to Gerrit? Updating a remote url is the most annoying step when a user needs to migrate to Gerrit for the first time. No, SSH URLs cannot be redirected. That would be a man-in-the-middle attack :) Gerrit also uses a different host key, and it also uses different https passwords. (In reply to Mike Milinkovich from comment #6) > Can someone help me understand what my workflow will become? Does this mean > that after I commit the code from Orion that I will need to also interact > with Gerrit? Hi Mike, Your workflow does not change, the only thing that changes is that URLs you use to push/pull so you will need to update existing repo URLs you are working on. In Orion you can change this by going to the "Git repo view -> Configuration -> remote.origin.url" and setting it to the URL that Gerrit gives you for the repo. Once that's configured... If you use "https" to connect then Gerrit does not allow you to use your eclipse.org password, Gerrit will generate you a random password which you need to use. You can find this in Gerrit at this URL after you login https://git.eclipse.org/r/#/settings/http-password If you use "ssh" to connect you will need to add your public SSH key to this URL https://git.eclipse.org/r/#/settings/ssh-keys I think the key thing to keep in mind in the immediate future is that you can ignore the fact that Gerrit's running in the backend and use it as you were using Git before, only the URLs you use to push / pull is different. In the longer term we can setup a demo for everyone on how to use Gerrit specific features but this isn't mandatory for using Gerrit. Thanks for all the help Thanh and Eddie. I'm up and running on Gerrit now. (At least for the repos I use that have switched.) (In reply to Edouard Poitras from comment #7) Now that Luna's been released we should look into enabling Gerrit for the remaining repos from Eddie's list in comment 7. I can look into doing this, this afternoon if there is no objections. (In reply to Edouard Poitras from comment #7) Now that Luna's been released we should look into enabling Gerrit for the remaining repos from Eddie's list in comment 7. I can look into doing this, this afternoon if there is no objections. Doesn't matter to me, as long as we can identify who commits there, as well as help them update their remotes. 10years : Chris arch : Denis callisto : Nathan / Matt / Wayne contribute : Chris / Wayne documentation : Matt / Denis / Wayne errors : Denis europa : galileo : ganymede : go : Denis images : Mike / Denis / Wayne / Chris / Andrew / Anne indigo : Wayne / Chris / David Williams juno : Chris kepler : Chris legal : Chris / Mike / Sharon / Ian / Matt / Wayne licenses : Mike / Denis luna : Chris / Wayne / Chris Aniszczyk mail : Denis / Wayne / Matt / Chris mobile : Chris mpc : Ian / Carsten Reckord newsgroups : Denis / Matt phoenix-test : Denis screenshots : Wayne Notes: phoenix-test only has a single commit stating that it's a test commit. Do we even need this repo? is it worth even keeping around? I think the 2 repos that we may need to help people setup are "images" and "legal". The other repos seem to be only committers who are all part of the technical team. Also MPC is a project, does this really count as EMO? But I guess it only affects Carsten and Ian so maybe we can open a bug and ask if they want MPC to be Gerrit enabled. > Notes: > > phoenix-test only has a single commit stating that it's a test commit. Do we > even need this repo? is it worth even keeping around? > I have a bug for this, Bug 433038 - Remove /phoenix-test/ from production (In reply to Thanh Ha from comment #20) I've enabled Gerrit on all the repos listed in comment 20 except for: - mpc - phoenix-test Ian, I think you're the Project Lead for MPC. Let me know if you think it makes sense for us to enable Gerrit for MPC. Also, If anyone needs help updating your Git setup to use the Gerrit URLs feel free to contact me and I can walk you through the process. (In reply to Thanh Ha from comment #22) > Also, If anyone needs help updating your Git setup to use the Gerrit URLs > feel free to contact me and I can walk you through the process. Thanh, I haven't been able to do anything in the foundation or community repos since the change to Gerrit. I'm pretty sure you can fix that in about five minutes when we see each other in Ottawa nest week. So let's plan on that. (In reply to Anne Jacko from comment #23) > Thanh, I haven't been able to do anything in the foundation or community > repos since the change to Gerrit. I'm pretty sure you can fix that in about > five minutes when we see each other in Ottawa nest week. So let's plan on > that. I helped Anne with this when she was in Ottawa last week. I think we're done here. Is there anything left to do? or can we close this? > I think we're done here. Is there anything left to do? or can we close this? Is everyone identified in comment 20 up-to-date with references to Gerrit? (In reply to Denis Roy from comment #25) > > I think we're done here. Is there anything left to do? or can we close this? > > Is everyone identified in comment 20 up-to-date with references to Gerrit? I'm not but that is completely my fault. Not enough time to take Thanh up on his kind offer. I need to reinstall Eclipse again, etc., etc. Oddly enough I have some kind friends in high places that don't mind posting a change here or there for me the odd time I need one made. Regards, Sharon I think we've done everything we could here. |