Some Eclipse Foundation services are deprecated, or will be soon. Please ensure you've read this important communication.

Bug 354102

Summary:	[team] SVN commit comment is not getting populated from commit template
Product:	[Technology] Subversive	Reporter:	Sébastien Gandon <sgandon>
Component:	Integrations	Assignee:	Igor Burilo <igor.burilo>
Status:	RESOLVED WONTFIX	QA Contact:
Severity:	normal
Priority:	P3	CC:	begraves, steffen.pingel
Version:	unspecified
Target Milestone:	---
Hardware:	Macintosh
OS:	Mac OS X - Carbon (unsup.)
Whiteboard:

Description Sébastien Gandon

2011-08-08 01:55:22 EDT

Build Identifier: 

I am using Subversive for svn Jira connector for Mylyn.
When commiting to Svn, the comments are not set with the Mylyn template.
I have on both on Indigo or Helios my Mylyn 3.6 (the latest release as of today) and they both fail.
I have tried on Helios, the previous release of Mylyn 3.4 and it works like a charm.
There seems to be a problem with the latest 3.6 release in that mater.

Reproducible: Always

Steps to Reproduce:
1. dowload Indigo RCP and Rap package, install all subversive plugin (including team provider) 
2.install jira connector.
3.modify some code
4.open the commit dialog
No comments there.

Comment 1 Steffen Pingel

2011-08-08 06:41:04 EDT

You need to install the Subversive Mylyn Integration in order to get this functionality.

Moving to Subversive project in case there is something else broken.

Comment 2 Sébastien Gandon

2011-08-08 08:35:52 EDT

I did install 
  Subversive SVN Integration for the Mylyn Project (Optional) (Incubation)	0.7.9.I20110602-1700	org.eclipse.team.svn.mylyn.feature.group	Eclipse.org
feature also but the problem is still there.

Comment 3 Steffen Pingel

2011-08-08 11:27:35 EDT

I also recommend verifying the requirements for (CVS) change set tracking listed in the FAQ: http://wiki.eclipse.org/Mylyn/FAQ#Why_does_task_change_set_not_appear_when_I_modify_files.3F

Comment 4 Sébastien Gandon

2011-08-08 21:57:11 EDT

yes verified it all but still not working.
here is a list of the features installed :
*** Features:
com.atlassian.connector.eclipse.jira (3.0.0.v20110210) "Atlassian Connector for Eclipse Branding"
com.atlassian.connector.eclipse.monitor (3.0.0.v20110210) "Atlassian Connector for Eclipse Branding"
org.eclipse.cvs (1.3.100.v20110520-0800-7B78FHk8sF7BB7SBB5EYD5) "Eclipse CVS Client"
org.eclipse.egit (1.0.0.201106090707-r) "Git Team Provider"
org.eclipse.emf.mwe.ui (1.1.0.v201106070424) "MWE UI "
org.eclipse.epp.mpc (1.1.0.I20110525-0742) "Marketplace Client"
org.eclipse.epp.package.rcp.feature (1.4.0.20110615-0550) "EPP RCP/RAP Bundle"
org.eclipse.help (1.3.0.v20110327-7i7uFFiFFt6ZqnbOrMXLd1) "Help System Base"
org.eclipse.jdt (3.7.0.v20110520-0800-7z8gFchFMTdFYKuLqBLqRja9B15B) "Eclipse Java Development Tools"
org.eclipse.jgit (1.0.0.201106090707-r) "JGit Core"
org.eclipse.mylyn_feature (3.6.1.v20110728-0200) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.bugzilla_feature (3.6.0.v20110608-1400) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.context_feature (3.6.1.v20110728-0200) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.ide_feature (3.6.1.v20110728-0200) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.java_feature (3.6.1.v20110728-0200) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.jira_feature (3.4.0) "Atlassian Connector for Eclipse Branding"
org.eclipse.mylyn.pde_feature (3.6.1.v20110728-0200) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.team_feature (3.6.1.v20110728-0200) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.wikitext_feature (1.5.1.v20110728-0200) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.pde (3.7.0.v20110504-0800-7b7qFVpFEx2XnmYtj_9RfO7) "PDE"
org.eclipse.platform (3.7.0.v20110530-9gF7UHNFFt4cwE-pkZDJ7oz-mj4OSEIlu9SEv0f) "Eclipse Platform"
org.eclipse.rcp (3.7.0.v20110216-9DB5Fm1FpBGy_AaVz-mFamgY) "Eclipse RCP"
org.eclipse.team.svn (0.7.9.I20110724-1700) "Subversive SVN Team Provider (Incubation)"
org.eclipse.team.svn.mylyn (0.7.9.I20110602-1700) "Subversive Integration for the Mylyn Project (Incubation)"
org.eclipse.wst.xml_ui.feature (3.3.0.v201103310011-7H7EFZ-DxumTla66ahfUnHfpsz0u5Z92pU4TxSL) "Eclipse XML Editors and Tools"
org.eclipse.xpand (1.1.0.v201106070515) "Xpand core "
org.eclipse.xpand.ui (1.1.0.v201106070515) "Xpand editor "
org.eclipse.xtend (1.1.0.v201106070515) "Xtend core "
org.eclipse.xtend.typesystem.emf (1.1.0.v201106070515) "Xtend emf typesystem "
org.eclipse.xtend.ui (1.1.0.v201106070515) "Xtend UI "
org.eclipse.xtext.docs (2.0.0.v201106070531) "Xtext Documentation "
org.eclipse.xtext.sdk (2.0.0.v201106070531) "Xtext "
org.eclipse.xtext.ui (2.0.0.v201106070531) "Xtext UI Core "
org.eclipse.xtext.xbase (2.0.0.v201106070531) "Xbase Model "
org.eclipse.xtext.xtext.ui (2.0.0.v201106070531) "Xtext Xtext UI "
org.polarion.eclipse.team.svn.connector (2.2.2.I20110715-1700) "Subversive SVN Connectors"
org.polarion.eclipse.team.svn.connector.svnkit16 (2.2.2.I20110715-1700) "Subversive SVN 1.6 SVN Kit Connector"

Comment 5 begraves

2011-08-11 09:34:49 EDT

I ran into the very same problem - any news regarding this?

Comment 6 Sébastien Gandon

2011-08-12 11:33:29 EDT

This is working for me with the latest atlassian jira connector (3.0.1) released today (12 august 2011).
This can be close if you will.

Comment 7 Alexander Gurov

2011-08-13 04:30:25 EDT

Thank you for all the information provided. I've checked how integration works with Bugzilla and Trac connectors and found that it works just fine. Also considering it works with the latest Jira connector too I'll assume it was Jira connector-related issue.

Comment 8 Steffen Pingel

2011-08-31 10:39:43 EDT

Some changes were made to the monitoring of files that get added to change sets in Mylyn 3.6: bug 162007. I wonder if this has caused a regression with the SVN integrations.

If anyone is still experiencing problems with the automatic commit message please post your Mylyn and Eclipse platform version and if this was previously working, the version you were using before. Thanks.

Comment 9 Sébastien Gandon

2011-09-01 03:38:28 EDT

I thought the pb was corrected with the latest Jira Connector but this is not the case.
I now get automatic comments but they are not related to the active task.
It is as if the comment was using the task that was active the first time a modification occured.
But when I switch task and try to commit the modification on this task, I always get the comment of the previous task. 
I do not think that is expected.


*** Features:
com.atlassian.connector.commons (3.0.1.v20110812) "Atlassian Connector for Eclipse Branding"
com.atlassian.connector.eclipse (3.0.1.v20110812) "Atlassian Connector for Eclipse Branding"
com.atlassian.connector.eclipse.bamboo (3.0.1.v20110812) "Atlassian Connector for Eclipse Branding"
com.atlassian.connector.eclipse.commons (3.0.1.v20110812) "Atlassian Connector for Eclipse Branding"
com.atlassian.connector.eclipse.crucible (3.0.1.v20110812) "Atlassian Connector for Eclipse Branding"
com.atlassian.connector.eclipse.jira (3.0.1.v20110812) "Atlassian Connector for Eclipse Branding"
com.atlassian.connector.eclipse.monitor (3.0.1.v20110812) "Atlassian Connector for Eclipse Branding"
....
org.eclipse.mylyn_feature (3.6.1.v20110728-0200) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.bugzilla_feature (3.6.0.v20110608-1400) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.context_feature (3.6.1.v20110728-0200) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.cvs (0.8.0.v20110608-1400) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.git (0.8.0.v20110608-1400) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.ide_feature (3.6.1.v20110728-0200) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.java_feature (3.6.1.v20110728-0200) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.jira_feature (3.4.0) "Atlassian Connector for Eclipse Branding"
org.eclipse.mylyn.pde_feature (3.6.1.v20110728-0200) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.team_feature (3.6.1.v20110728-0200) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.versions (0.8.0.v20110608-1400) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.versions.sdk (0.8.0.v20110608-1400) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.mylyn.wikitext_feature (1.5.1.v20110728-0200) "Mylyn"
org.eclipse.pde (3.7.0.v20110504-0800-7b7qFVpFEx2XnmYtj_9RfO7) "PDE"
org.eclipse.platform (3.7.0.v20110530-9gF7UHNFFt4cwE-pkZDJ7oz-mj4OSEIlu9SEv0f) "Eclipse Platform"
org.eclipse.rcp (3.7.0.v20110216-9DB5Fm1FpBGy_AaVz-mFamgY) "Eclipse RCP"
org.eclipse.team.svn (0.7.9.I20110724-1700) "Subversive SVN Team Provider (Incubation)"
org.eclipse.team.svn.mylyn (0.7.9.I20110602-1700) "Subversive Integration for the Mylyn Project (Incubation)"
....
org.polarion.eclipse.team.svn.connector (2.2.2.I20110715-1700) "Subversive SVN Connectors"
org.polarion.eclipse.team.svn.connector.svnkit16 (2.2.2.I20110715-1700) "Subversive SVN 1.6 SVN Kit Connector"