Bugzilla – Full Text Bug Listing
| Summary: | Update TPTP matrix | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Product: | z_Archived | Reporter: | Hubert Leung <hkyleung> |
| Component: | TPTP | Assignee: | jkubasta |
| Status: | CLOSED FIXED | QA Contact: | |
| Severity: | normal | ||
| Priority: | P1 | CC: | jcayne, paulslau, slavescu |
| Version: | unspecified | Keywords: | plan |
| Target Milestone: | --- | Flags: | jkubasta:
review?
(sluiman) jptoomey: review? guru.nagarajan: review+ jkubasta: review? (smith) jptoomey: review+ paulslau: review+ |
| Hardware: | PC | ||
| OS: | Windows XP | ||
| Whiteboard: | closed460 | ||
| Bug Depends on: | |||
| Bug Blocks: | 194925 | ||
| Attachments: | |||
|
Description
Hubert Leung
Need baseline shown on a matrix Please review http://www.eclipse.org/tptp/home/project_info/structure/TPTP_Project_Info.html and let me know of any required changes by Thursday. Please also review the unassigned plugins http://www.eclipse.org/tptp/home/project_info/structure/Unassigned_Plugins.txt and let me know where they belong. Comments: 1. This link doesn't work : TPTP 4.x bugzilla component owners ( under the 'When a bugzilla is opened against a component in TPTP 4.0 or later, the person named in this list becomes the default owner:') 2. Typo on the first line ( release ): This page shows the TPTP project structure of the relesae under development. 3. Comments on the TPTP Project Component Structure table Some of the names displayed are not for active committers. Changes required : - Navid Mehregani Platform.Integrated Agent Controller - Anthony Miguel Platform.Execution.Choreography ( I don't think we have this component in the current stream ) - Navid Mehregani Platform.Execution.ProbekitBCI ( I can take the ownership as I am already owning the Probekit editor ) - Hubert Leung Build - Hubert is no longer an active committer in TPTP - Kent Siefkes Test.Execution - not an active committer - Balan Subramanian Monitor.UI.WSDMTooling - moved under the COSMOS project 4. Comments on the Component Level Plug-in Mapping with Committers table Inactive committers : Sri, Hendra, Alex Iskold, Nellie Chau, Kari, Navid, Curtis, George Christelis, Neil Are these TPTP committers ? Emmanuel W, Kim L, Kent,Javier G, Jon H, David Hodges 5. On the committers list ( under 'The following table shows the list of all TPTP committers, and their access permissions to TPTP resources.' ) I question the access for these people since they are inactive TPTP committers Andrew Eberbach, Alex Iskold, Bob Duncan, Christophe Telep, Curtis D'Entremont, David Hodges, Dan Price, Emmanuel Wurth, Hendra Suwanda, Jon Hoover, Karla , Kim, Kari, Ling, Melanie, Nellie, Navid, Neil, Robert Danek, Mike Boyersmith, Serge Lucio, Tyler For the unassigned plugins : org.eclipse.tptp.platform.probekit.launch - Probekit BCI ( owned by Valentina) Reviewed and approved with the assumption that my comments will be reviewed and resolved before committing these content. Thanks Valentina. Re the committer list, the list is automatically generated. I will ask Hubert if we can put back the inactive flag/designation Created attachment 71614 [details]
Patch for release typo and 4.4 link
Created attachment 71619 [details]
Updates to components, cmponent committers and probekit.launch plugin
Created attachment 71620 [details]
HTML including the above two patches
Valentina, please review the above files to ensure you are satisfied with the correction of your noted changes (with the exception of the automatically generated committer list at the end of file) The committers for the Execution.Framework component seem to be incomplete. I looked at he CVS history of the Matrix document for this component (which is bound to the org.eclipse.hyades.execution project in CVS), and it seems to have been wrong since since the initial version of the matrix document (when Sri was listed as the owners and there were no committers listed.) This project contains the entire old execution framework (which both Samson and I have made many fixes to over the past few years), as well as the base Automatable Services Framework and the Java File System Services components. At a minimum, both Samson and I should be added as committers to this component. I'm not sure what the policy should be w.r.t. voting for this change, as we have both been acting committers on the component since Hyades. Choreography is no longer a component of TPTP Stats/Perf Viewers need a new active committer owner Test Model should be owned by Joe Toomey OS Perfmon needs a new active committer owner for the committer matrix, I thought this was going ot be generated based on the ACLs in CVS and bugzilla. I see names I don't recognize and of inactive committers. The access is automatically generated from the ACLs in CVS. I have added a column to the table to show active/inactive committers. If we want the inactive committers removed from the table we need to send a note to the web master revoking their access. Created attachment 71970 [details]
refreshed HTML file
Created attachment 71972 [details]
Further updates reflecting in html
Updated plugin committers based on inactive committers. Note I left Andrew Eberbach as active as I believe this is the case. I also left Neil, Anthony and George as active for teh time being. Pls let me know if you want this changed Would like to close on this today if possible. Please link here for latest http://www.eclipse.org/tptp/home/project_info/structure/TPTP_Project_Info.html (In reply to comment #17) > Would like to close on this today if possible. Please link here for latest > http://www.eclipse.org/tptp/home/project_info/structure/TPTP_Project_Info.html > Sorry for the late reply. Comments: 1) Add 'Hyades' before 'version 3.3' in the second sentence since the first TPTP release was 4.0. Also, change 'TPTP 3.3' to 'Hyades 3.3'. Finally, consider changing 'TPTP 3.3 bugzilla component owners' to 'Hyades bugzilla component owners' and 'TPTP 4.x bugzilla component owners' to 'TPTP bugzilla component owners'. 2) Change 'Analysis' to 'Analysis Rules'. 3) Kent Siefkes is the owner of the Test.Execution component in Bugzilla. Can we access the Bugzilla component/owner list to update this matrix. 4) There is no ASF.Runtime component in Bugzilla. 5) Harm Sluiman is the owner of the Test.Model component in Bugzilla. This should be changed to Joe Toomey in Bugzilla. 6) Change 'JUniter' to 'JUnit'. 7) Test.Web is still an active Bugzilla component that should be removed in place of TPTP.Web. 8) Change 'plugin(s)' to 'plug-in(s)'. 9) For the list of plug-ins not assigned to a project, the following changes are required: -org.eclipse.hyades.test.ui.extensions belongs to the Test.UI.ConfigEditors Bugzilla component. -org.eclipse.tptp.test.tools.junit.plugin belongs to the Test.Execution.JUnitRunner and Test.UI.JUnit Bugzilla components. -org.eclipse.tptp.test.tools is a branding plug-in. It belongs to the Test project and is packaged with the driver so it should probably belong to the Test.UI Bugzilla component. 10) The project tables should have the Bugzilla component column (possibly removing it from the 'TPTP Project Component Structure' table) to make the association between plug-ins and Bugzilla components. 11) Change 'Test.UI.AutoGUIRunner' to 'Test.UI.AutoGUIUI' and the associated component name to 'Auto GUI UI'. This will also need to be changed in Bugzilla (I have sent a note to the Eclipse Webmaster). 12) The plug-in for the Test.UI.AutoGUIRunner (Test.UI.AutoGUIUI) and Test.Execution.AutoGUIRunner Bugzilla components is org.eclipse.tptp.test.auto.gui. 13) Kent Siefkes is a developer committer on the URL Runner component. 14) The Test.Model Bugzilla component is the org.eclipse.tptp.platform.models plug-in. Also, we should only include the committers listed in the Platform.Model Bugzilla component since this is a new component: Harm Sluiman Marius Slavescu Bianca Jiang Scott Schneider Joe Toomey Dominique Guilbaud Antony Miguel 15) Kent Siefkes is still an active participant in the project. As such, I would assert he is still an active committer despite not having any CVS/Bugzilla activity. 16) Byron Seward's company is missing (e.g. N/A - Individual Contributor). Suggestions (post-4.4): 1) Can we have links in the Project, Component, and Lead Committer columns of the 'TPTP Project Component Structure' section pointing to the associated section later in the document? 2) We reference the Hyades 3.3 project structure, but I am wondering if we should have archived versions for all of the major releases. Reviewed (see comment #18). I have a few questions and comments about this new matrix document: - when and why were the Test.Model and GLA.Model components created (also what plugins are included there) - at some point Harm sent a note about my nomination as lead committer for the Platform.Model component (which should be the only TPTP model component), I still don't see that reflected in the matrix (in both tables, by component and by plugin) - Navid Mehregani shows up as IBM Toronto and No active I suppose it should be marked as "N/A - Individual Contributor" and active - I requested several times to create a common product where we can put the model component and other common components, I see that the bugzilla component column listed in the matrix doesn't include the product so it would be difficult to track it down from there. - I see several plugins in the http://www.eclipse.org/tptp/home/project_info/structure/Unassigned_Plugins.txt list which makes sense to be part of a TPTP project I would like to help fix the matrix and add the missing information. It seems that "Test Model" component contains org.eclipse.hyades.test.tools.core plugin, but the same plugin (and only one) is actually part of 9 components (including Test Model): Auto GUI Runner Common Runner Execution Harness JUniter Runner Manual Runner URL Runner Test Model Manual Test Editor Manual Test Client I see the need for more then one Bugzilla component for main functions in a plugin, but having 9 components for one plugin looks a bit overloaded. Would be probably better if we use in both sets of tables the Bugzilla component (including the Bugzilla product) and rename the "Component" column to "Component description" (before was "Technology" see http://www.eclipse.org/tptp/home/project_info/structure/TPTP_Project_Matrix.html) and add a bit of description there. re comment 18: 1) Add 'Hyades' before 'version 3.3' in the second sentence since the first TPTP release was 4.0. Also, change 'TPTP 3.3' to 'Hyades 3.3'. Finally, consider changing 'TPTP 3.3 bugzilla component owners' to 'Hyades bugzilla component owners' and 'TPTP 4.x bugzilla component owners' to 'TPTP bugzilla component owners'. >>> changes made 2) Change 'Analysis' to 'Analysis Rules'. >>> Globally? 3) Kent Siefkes is the owner of the Test.Execution component in Bugzilla. Can we access the Bugzilla component/owner list to update this matrix. >>> Update made 4) There is no ASF.Runtime component in Bugzilla. >>> yes there is. It was one of the adds done via another defect (Word document that Valentina managed). Can be found under TPTP ASF 5) Harm Sluiman is the owner of the Test.Model component in Bugzilla. This should be changed to Joe Toomey in Bugzilla. >>> Please open a defect against release engineering 6) Change 'JUniter' to 'JUnit'. >> Change made 7) Test.Web is still an active Bugzilla component that should be removed in place of TPTP.Web. >> Bugzilla change. Please include in rel eng defect requested above 8) Change 'plugin(s)' to 'plug-in(s)'. >>> Change made 9) For the list of plug-ins not assigned to a project, the following changes are required: -org.eclipse.hyades.test.ui.extensions belongs to the Test.UI.ConfigEditors Bugzilla component. -org.eclipse.tptp.test.tools.junit.plugin belongs to the Test.Execution.JUnitRunner and Test.UI.JUnit Bugzilla components. -org.eclipse.tptp.test.tools is a branding plug-in. It belongs to the Test project and is packaged with the driver so it should probably belong to the Test.UI Bugzilla component. >>> All changes made 10) The project tables should have the Bugzilla component column (possibly removing it from the 'TPTP Project Component Structure' table) to make the association between plug-ins and Bugzilla components. >>> I look at this suggestion later today. May defer to 4.4.0.1 11) Change 'Test.UI.AutoGUIRunner' to 'Test.UI.AutoGUIUI' and the associated component name to 'Auto GUI UI'. This will also need to be changed in Bugzilla (I have sent a note to the Eclipse Webmaster). >> Update to matrix made 12) The plug-in for the Test.UI.AutoGUIRunner (Test.UI.AutoGUIUI) and Test.Execution.AutoGUIRunner Bugzilla components is org.eclipse.tptp.test.auto.gui. >>> added 13) Kent Siefkes is a developer committer on the URL Runner component. >> added 14) The Test.Model Bugzilla component is the org.eclipse.tptp.platform.models plug-in. Also, we should only include the committers listed in the Platform.Model Bugzilla component since this is a new component: Harm Sluiman Marius Slavescu Bianca Jiang Scott Schneider Joe Toomey Dominique Guilbaud Antony Miguel >>> changes made 15) Kent Siefkes is still an active participant in the project. As such, I would assert he is still an active committer despite not having any CVS/Bugzilla activity. >>> updated matrix 16) Byron Seward's company is missing (e.g. N/A - Individual Contributor). >>> left intel. This info is automatically generated and I cannot update it. I recommend revoking his access if he is no longer an active contributor Suggestions (post-4.4): 1) Can we have links in the Project, Component, and Lead Committer columns of the 'TPTP Project Component Structure' section pointing to the associated section later in the document? >>> will consider later today 2) We reference the Hyades 3.3 project structure, but I am wondering if we should have archived versions for all of the major releases. >> will consider later today >>> ALL incorporated changes viewable on web link now. Thanks for reviewing re comment 20: I have a few questions and comments about this new matrix document: - when and why were the Test.Model and GLA.Model components created (also what plugins are included there) >>> These were added as part of a bugzilla component overhaul in the last few weeks (i.e. Word doc referenced in my last append). If the plugins may well be wrong, hence the request for review. - at some point Harm sent a note about my nomination as lead committer for the Platform.Model component (which should be the only TPTP model component), I still don't see that reflected in the matrix (in both tables, by component and by plugin) >>> Yes I recall the note but need to ensure it went through appropriate approvals. - Navid Mehregani shows up as IBM Toronto and No active I suppose it should be marked as "N/A - Individual Contributor" and active >>> good idea. Will implement - I requested several times to create a common product where we can put the model component and other common components, I see that the bugzilla component column listed in the matrix doesn't include the product so it would be difficult to track it down from there. - I see several plugins in the http://www.eclipse.org/tptp/home/project_info/structure/Unassigned_Plugins.txt list which makes sense to be part of a TPTP project >>> As per platform meeting, please review plugin list (incl unassigned and append any necessary changes to this defect) I would like to help fix the matrix and add the missing information. >>> Thanks, I would appreciate the help : ) (In reply to comment #22) > 2) Change 'Analysis' to 'Analysis Rules'. > >>> Globally? Yes, in the context of the Test Project. > 4) There is no ASF.Runtime component in Bugzilla. > >>> yes there is. It was one of the adds done via another defect (Word document that Valentina managed). Can be found under TPTP ASF I see it. I was looking under the TPTP Testing product. We need to add the ASF Documentation Bugzilla component as well. > 5) Harm Sluiman is the owner of the Test.Model component in Bugzilla. This > should be changed to Joe Toomey in Bugzilla. > >>> Please open a defect against release engineering https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=194033 > 6) Change 'JUniter' to 'JUnit'. > >> Change made I believe there were a couple so we will need a global change. > 7) Test.Web is still an active Bugzilla component that should be removed in > place of TPTP.Web. > >> Bugzilla change. Please include in rel eng defect requested above https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=194033 > 10) The project tables should have the Bugzilla component column (possibly > removing it from the 'TPTP Project Component Structure' table) to make the > association between plug-ins and Bugzilla components. > >>> I look at this suggestion later today. May defer to 4.4.0.1 Sure. Changes made: 1. Analysis > Analysis Rules (under Test project, 2 instances) 2. Added ASF.Documentation, owner Joe, no associated plugins identified 3. Scanned both files for JUniter, and html page, no instances found. Can you provide the context? Thanks for opening the associated defect 10) The project tables should have the Bugzilla component column (possibly removing it from the 'TPTP Project Component Structure' table) to make the association between plug-ins and Bugzilla components. >>> Change made 1) Can we have links in the Project, Component, and Lead Committer columns of
the 'TPTP Project Component Structure' section pointing to the associated
section later in the document?
>>> Done
These changes were also made: - at some point Harm sent a note about my nomination as lead committer for the Platform.Model component (which should be the only TPTP model component), I still don't see that reflected in the matrix (in both tables, by component and by plugin) - Navid Mehregani shows up as IBM Toronto and No active I suppose it should be marked as "N/A - Individual Contributor" and active Today's changes will be reflected on web tomorrow Joel please replace the old matrix with the new Phoenix matrix and resolve this bug as fixed. Project leads: Please open defects for any additional updates against yourselves (content) or Joel (template). Joel, please regenerate the file first (Last night's run doesn't show Harm as a Model committer due to a typo I made -- and have now fixed) The matrix has been regenerated and the link to the old matrix updated to point to the new matrix. fixed As of TPTP 4.6.0, TPTP is in maintenance mode and focusing on improving quality by resolving relevant enhancements/defects and increasing test coverage through test creation, automation, Build Verification Tests (BVTs), and expanded run-time execution. As part of the TPTP Bugzilla housecleaning process (see http://wiki.eclipse.org/Bugzilla_Housecleaning_Processes), this enhancement/defect is verified/closed by the Project Lead since the originator of this enhancement/defect has an inactive Bugzilla account and considered to be fixed. If this enhancement/defect is still unresolved and reproducible in the latest TPTP release (http://www.eclipse.org/tptp/home/downloads/), please re-open. |